SPP is a beautiful idea that combines classic computer visions idea to the modern neural network. Contrary to the convolution operation, pooling has no parameters. The automated pipeline has a unique, state-of-the-art architecture with visualisation screens at par or superior to other GIS data competitors. It keeps the average value of the values that appear within the filter, as images are ultimately a set of well arranged numeric data. Computer Vision Researcher| ML Technical Writer | Connect with me on LinkedIn https://www.linkedin.com/in/prasant-kumar-a510bb192/, https://www.linkedin.com/in/prasant-kumar-a510bb192/. 3 Data Science Projects That Got Me 12 Interviews. The matrix used in this coding example represents grayscale image of blocks as visible below. Pooling layers is a big mistake because it loses a lot of valuable information and it ignores the relation between the part and the whole if we are talking about a face detector so we have to combine some features (mouth, 2 eyes, face oval and a nose) to say that is a face CNN would say if those 5 features present with high probability this would These values in the Feature map are showing How important a feature is and its location. They found that by introducing paramedical coverage into the plan, employees became less reliant on pharmaceutical pain management. Not all houses are the same and the size of the backyard also differs from house to house. For companies that are continually buffeted by benefit increases, additional pooling may be an option to consider. Stride - The number of steps a filter takes while traversing the image. Set Filter such that (0,0) element of feature matrix overlaps the (0,0) element of the filter. Above image might be interpreted as painting the entire area with the most pigmented colour. This is used to collapse your representation. It is essentially equivalent to our previous methods, with different hyperparameters. Average Pooling - The Average presence of features is reflected. It cannot be learnt through training. [+ Solutions for it], Learn more about the purpose of each operation of a Machine Learning model, Epoch, Iteration and Batch in Deep Learning. In this article, we have explored the significance or the importance of each layer in a Machine Learning model. If j < n then: Move filter s steps forward and reapeat steps 3,4,5, Else if i < m then: Increment i, move the filter such that (i,0) element of feature matrix overlaps (0,0) element of filter and Reapeat steps 3,4,5,6. Average pooling smoothly extracts features. Pooling, progressively reduces the size of feature maps, introducing Translational Invariance. 11 Conv followed by 22 average pooling are used as the transition layers between two contiguous dense blocks. In the above example you may observe that a layer forms a smaller feature map, the fiter size is 3x3 and the stride is 1 i.e. This is called Shift invariance. You may observe the varying nature of the filter. Disadvantages of laser welding. Pooling layers, also known as downsampling, conducts dimensionality reduction, reducing the number of parameters in the input. In this article, we have explored the idea and computation details regarding pooling layers in Machine Learning models and different types of pooling operations as well. The navigation system leverages proprietary Maisart compact AI technology to analyse multimodal sensing information and provide intuitive driving instructions. Spatial Pyramid Pooling (SPP) [1] is an excellent idea that does not need to resize an image before feeding to the neural network. There are many countries where the demand of land is higher for example Republic of Korea or Japan. We have taken an image of size 28*28. You must be thinking What is the importance of adding invariance in images. This can be achieved using MaxPooling2D layer in keras as follows: Average pooling computes the average of the elements present in the region of feature map covered by the filter. Let T() be a function the brings translational variance to a feature map X, the output after passing through the neural network NN() shall remain unchanged. All the three images on the left, gives the same image on the right, The rotation and size of image doesn't matter, only the presence at the top left corner. In this article, we have explored the idea and computation details regarding pooling layers in Machine Learning models and different types of pooling operations as well. To gain a better understanding of this, let us split the image into multiple parts. STORY: Kolmogorov N^2 Conjecture Disproved, STORY: man who refused $1M for his discovery, List of 100+ Dynamic Programming Problems, Large Counts Condition and Large Enough Sample Rule, Panoptic quality (PQ), segmentation quality (SQ) and recognition quality (RQ), Evaluation metrics for object detection and segmentation, What is overfitting? We're not sure though, whether the success of maxpooling is due to its intuitive approach or the fact that it has worked well in a lot of experiments. The operations are illustrated through the following figures. Is a hot staple gun good enough for interior switch repair. It is useful when the background of the image is dark and we are interested in only the lighter pixels of the image. :D, [1] Spatial Pyramid Pooling in Deep Convolutional Networks for Visual Recognition, ''' If we observe the feature maps performed by the convolution layers, they are sensitive to the location of the features in the input. 1. Pooling provides an approach to downsample feature maps by summarizing the presence of features in the feature maps. These concrete pools can be designed and can be built to complement the property and these concrete pools come in all shapes and sizes. Pheww, hope you enjoy it. Many a times, beginners blindly use a pooling method without knowing the reason for using it. Pooling is performed in neural networks to reduce variance and computation complexity. Any layer maybe defined by its hyperparameters. Artificial Intelligence Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for people interested in conceptual questions about life and challenges in a world where "cognitive" functions can be mimicked in purely digital environment. Hence, for a deep net you have no choice but to have groups of layers (convolutions) without dimensionality reduction, separated by layers that do dimensionality reduction. By using our site, you No knowledge of pooling layers is complete without knowing Average Pooling and Maximum Pooling! Many a times, beginners blindly use a pooling method without knowing the reason for using it. As a result we obtain a coarse output (refer the illustration below). 2. perfect when orthology matters or if you are working with characters such as emojis or byte 3. great for short texts (e.g., headline. In short, in AvgPool, the average presence of features is highlighted while in MaxPool, specific features are highlighted irrespective of location. Not being exposed as an individual company or plan sponsor to large and infrequent claims such as life insurance claims, Increased rate stability from year to year, The ability to offer employees important drug coverage that they could not obtain on their own through large-claim pooling limits. The connection pool that is between the client and the database, can provide handy features such as "ping" test, connection retry, etc. Let's address this. One major issue with in-network Downsampling in a FCN is that it reduces the resolution of the input by a large factor, thus during upsampling it becomes very difficult to reproduce the finer details even after using sophisticated techniques like Transpose Convolution. Global pooling reduces each channel in the feature map to a single value. previous_conv_size: an int vector [height, width] of the matrix features size of previous convolution layer There are three parameters the describe a pooling layer. Pricing of pooled benefits is based on age, gender, occupation, etc. As a whole, convolutional layers in the Deep Neural Networks form parts of objects and finally objects which can summarize the features in an input image. Pooling with the average values. Pooling . Here, we need to select a pooling layer. To solve this problem, 1x1 conv blocks are introduced to the naive Inception module to create a complete Inception module. No, CNN is complete without pooling layers, Inputs are multichanneled images. The pooling layer summarises the features present in a region of the feature map generated by a convolution layer. Whether sitting straight, or laying upside down. We must be thinking that Is downscaling the images is the only use of it. What makes CNNs different is that unlike regular neural networks they work on volumes of data. You can monitor the pool, see the number of active connections, etc. it moves one step at a time. This problem was one of the bigger motivators for researchers throughout the decades, even David Marr with his primal sketches. A filter with stride two must move two steps at a time. In short, the different types of pooling operations are: Maximum Pool. Stride = 2. Max-Pooling picks the maximum value from that set which is 8. Do German ministers decide themselves how to vote in EU decisions or do they have to follow a government line? A company had been with a completely pooled program for many years but had never really communicated the benefits plan to employees. Sanjay Bhargava stepped down as Starlink Country Director, India, just four months after his appointment. Pooling in the insurance industry . Employers with fewer than 10 employee lives have the most choices, but new programs in the marketplace are offering completely pooled programs to larger organizations as well. Feature map sizes are the same within the dense block so that they can be concatenated together easily. I also heard that many max-pooling layers have been replaced by convolutional layers in recent years, is that true? (2) If the weldment requires the use of a fixture, it should be . In this article, we have explored the difference between MaxPool and AvgPool operations (in ML models) in depth. In addition to that, we need predominant features to be extracted such as the eye of the cat, which acts as a differentiator to identify the image. The other image contains only the head of the cat. If you notice this, you are already versed with a famous pooling layer called the max-pooling layer. As a whole, convolutional layers in the Deep Neural Networks form parts of objects and finally objects which can summarize the features in an input image. Scale Invariance(Invariance in Scale(small or big)). After that, we train the parameters in each batch, then transfer them to another batch. SPP is inspired from: Pyramid (image processing . Pooling layer is an important building block of a Convolutional Neural Network. Max Pooling is a convolution process where the Kernel extracts the maximum value of the area it convolves. Disadvantages of the land pooling Not just benefits but there are also many disadvantages of the land pooling. out_pool_size: a int vector of expected output size of max pooling layer So, taking only the maximum value means extracting the most important feature in a region. At best, max pooling is a less than optimal method to reduce feature matrix complexity and therefore over/under fitting and improve model generalization(for translation invariant classes). In this image, if you can reach a receptive field of 5*5, you can find some features visible. This can be addressed by downsampling the feature maps. Following figures illustrate the effects of pooling on two images with different content. We saw the intuition of max pooling in the previous example. After some convolution and pooling layer, we have a matrix features with size \(f_d \times f_h \times f_w\). In short, the different types of pooling operations are: In the picture below, they both are cats! That information can offer insight into a groups state of being and potential strategies to improve the health and wellness of their team. of the plan members within a particular company. With that, a plan sponsors arent provided with any detailed claim information. It keeps the maximum value of the values that appear within the filter, as images are ultimately set of well arranged numeric data. When and how was it discovered that Jupiter and Saturn are made out of gas? Discover special offers, top stories, upcoming events, and more. How does the NLT translate in Romans 8:2? How to Choose the Optimal Learning Rate for Neural Networks. The difficulty of collecting fault data samples is one of the application problems of the deep learning method in fault diagnosis of mechanical production; the second is that when the depth of the. The most common type of pooling is max poolingwhich just takes the max value in the pooling window. You may observe by above two cases, same kind of image, by exchanging foreground and background brings a drastic impact on the effectiveness of the output of the max pooling layer, whereas the average pooling maintains its smooth and average character. Pooling layers are used to reduce the dimensions of the feature maps. Spatial pooling is also called downsampling or . Pricing in pooled benefit plans tends to be removed from that groups own experience. The output of the pooling method varies with the varying value of the filter size. Large claim pooling is especially relevant for benefit plans with unlimited drug maximums. So we need to generalise the presence of features. Below is the formula and calculation for the case drawn just after the formula. ReLU) has been applied to the feature maps output by a convolutional layer; for example the layers in a model may look as follows: Input Image Convolutional Layer Nonlinearity Pooling Layer SPP is inspired from: In this note, I am going to show mathematic inside before porting it into tensorflow version and analyzing upside and downside of it. A-143, 9th Floor, Sovereign Corporate Tower, We use cookies to ensure you have the best browsing experience on our website. Downscaling Image by extracting most important feature, 2. A filter with stride one must move one step at a time. But also now one can aim for really deep networks (number of layers) with the same complexity as before. is that the best that we can do? Stay Connected with a larger ecosystem of data science and ML Professionals. Its not advised to do Max pooling in the initial stages of the Convolutional Neural Network as the Kernels would be at the stage of extracting edges and gradients. It removes a lesser chunk of data in comparison to Max Pooling. Average pooling: The average value of all the pixels in the batch is selected. The idea must get clear by looking at our classic example. 16-17th Mar, 2023 | BangaloreRising 2023 | Women in Tech Conference, 27-28th Apr, 2023 I BangaloreData Engineering Summit (DES) 202327-28th Apr, 2023, 23 Jun, 2023 | BangaloreMachineCon India 2023 [AI100 Awards], 21 Jul, 2023 | New YorkMachineCon USA 2023 [AI100 Awards]. I hope all your concepts are cleared. Below is an example of the same, using Keras library. When you input an image in a ConvNet, each layer generates several activation . Advantages of Concrete Pools -. This button displays the currently selected search type. Slight change or shift does not cause invariance as we get max value from the 2 *2 image. Get this book -> Problems on Array: For Interviews and Competitive Programming. previous_conv: a tensor vector of previous convolution layer I have just analysis some idea of SPP. Therefore, Similar to the convolutional layer, the pooling operation sweeps a filter across the entire input, but the difference is that this filter does not have any weights. Convolutional neural networks are composed of multiple layers of artificial neurons. Creative idea. In this article, we have explored the two important concepts namely boolean and none in Python. Hence, filter must be configured to be most suited to your requirements, and input image to get the best results. While selecting a layer you must be well versed with: Average pooling retains a lot of data, whereas max pooling rejects a big chunk of data The aims behind this are: Hence, Choice of pooling method is dependent on the expectations from the pooling layer and the CNN. Translational Invariance maybe defined as the ability to ignore positional shifts or translations in the target image. Output Matrix Max Pooling. You may observe the greatest values from 2x2 blocks retained. Pooling is "downscaling" of the image obtained from the previous layers. Selective Search for Object Detection | R-CNN. A Convolutional layer have a set of matrices that get multiplied by the previous layer output in a process called the convolution to detect some features this features could be basic features (e.g. To know which pooling layer works the best, you must know how does pooling help. If high-cost drugs hit a particular plan for two years or more, the cost of these prescriptions would be shared by the entire group of over 23 participating companies. acknowledge that you have read and understood our, Data Structure & Algorithm Classes (Live), Data Structure & Algorithm-Self Paced(C++/JAVA), Android App Development with Kotlin(Live), Full Stack Development with React & Node JS(Live), GATE CS Original Papers and Official Keys, ISRO CS Original Papers and Official Keys, ISRO CS Syllabus for Scientist/Engineer Exam, Python | Image Classification using Keras, Applying Convolutional Neural Network on mnist dataset, Long Short Term Memory Networks Explanation, Deep Learning | Introduction to Long Short Term Memory, LSTM Derivation of Back propagation through time, Deep Neural net with forward and back propagation from scratch Python, Python implementation of automatic Tic Tac Toe game using random number, Python program to implement Rock Paper Scissor game, Python | Program to implement Jumbled word game, Linear Regression (Python Implementation). Thus, the output after max-pooling layer would be a feature map containing the most prominent features of the previous feature map. How do you get out of a corner when plotting yourself into a corner. Priyanshi Sharma has been an Intern at Google in 2021 | Computer Science student at National Institute of Technology, Raipur | 2020 Intern at OpenGenus | Author of "Problems in AI" |. Max Pooling is advantageous because it adds translation invariance. Here is a comparison of three basic pooling methods that are widely used. How did StorageTek STC 4305 use backing HDDs? Disadvantage: Obtain the minimum value amongst the values overlapped by the filter. SWIFT is now leveraging transformative AI solutions by enabling a high-performance AI platform that is future-ready for hybrid cloud. Thus, it reduces the number of parameters to learn and the amount of computation performed in the network. CNNs with max pooling are more than capable of handling simple transformations like flips or rotation without too much trouble. The formulae can be inversely generated from the pooling formula. This is very similar to MaxPooling, here the minimum value is stored instead of the maximum one. For example if you are analyzing objects and the position of the object is important you shouldn't use it because the translational variance; if you just need to detect an object, it could help reducing the size of the matrix you are passing to the next convolutional layer. Average pooling method smooths out the image and hence the sharp features may not be identified when this pooling method is used. Thus, an. There are many advantages of using Max Pooling over other Pooling operations (Min Pooling and Average Pooling). Behind Mitsubishis AI-powered scene-aware interaction system, Wakefits Puneet Tripathi on how the love for maths shaped his data science career, You need empathy to become a good data scientist: Data Sutram co-founder Ankit Das, How to get multiple data science jobs offers as a college student, Despite all the bashing, why the open-source world still needs Meta. First, it takes a lot of time to train. The three types of pooling operations are: The batch here means a group of pixels of size equal to the filter size which is decided based on the size of the image. There are following types of it, 1. STORY: Kolmogorov N^2 Conjecture Disproved, STORY: man who refused $1M for his discovery, List of 100+ Dynamic Programming Problems, Large Counts Condition and Large Enough Sample Rule, Panoptic quality (PQ), segmentation quality (SQ) and recognition quality (RQ), Evaluation metrics for object detection and segmentation, What is overfitting? The pooling operation involves sliding a two-dimensional filter over each channel of feature map and summarising the features lying within the region covered by the filter. Share Improve this answer Follow edited May 31, 2020 at 10:08 esoteric-elliptic 1,051 3 17 answered May 30, 2020 at 16:04 Kaivalya Swami 86 1 8 Due to its depth and number of fully-connected nodes, the trained VGG16 model is over 500MB. But they present a problem, they're sensitive to location of features in the input. The pooling layer summarises the features present in a region of the feature map generated by a convolution layer. Because pricing is typically based on the performance of the entire block, plan sponsors will never know if their group is using their benefits. Max Pooling - The feature with the most activated presence shall shine through. What is the purpose of this D-shaped ring at the base of the tongue on my hiking boots? rev2023.3.1.43269. [+ Solutions for it], MaxPool vs AvgPool layers in Machine Learning models, Purpose of different layers in Machine Learning models, List of Machine Learning topics at OpenGenus, This is how Pooling layers are implemented in Keras library, Epoch, Iteration and Batch in Deep Learning. Tony Caas, CPCU, MBA, AU, ARM, ARe, AIC, AIS. Obtain the average value of all the values overlapped by the filter. And there you have it! Max pooling stores only pixels of the maximum value. Variations maybe obseved according to pixel density of the image, and size of filter used. Even dental and extended health care claims would be spread among many companies in the pool. Thus, while max pooling gives the most prominent feature in a particular patch of the feature map, average pooling gives the average of features present in a patch. Hinton perhaps sums the issues in his talk here on what is wrong with CNNs. Where the Kernel extracts the maximum one the minimum value is stored of. Pooling and average pooling are used as the ability to ignore positional shifts or translations in input! 11 Conv followed by 22 average pooling - the average presence of features is reflected for companies that are buffeted... Idea must get clear by looking at our classic example our site, you no knowledge of pooling &... Most suited to your requirements, and more i also heard that many max-pooling layers have been replaced by layers. Of feature matrix overlaps the ( 0,0 ) element of the image and hence the features... Inspired from: Pyramid ( image processing 28 * 28 basic pooling methods that are widely used for. And computation complexity the image two steps at a time also many disadvantages the. Have a matrix features with size \ ( f_d \times f_h \times )... Clear by looking at our classic example gain a better understanding of this, you monitor... Map to a single value dimensionality reduction, reducing the number of parameters in the pool claim information driving... Might be interpreted as painting the entire area with the same, using Keras library a matrix features with \. That, a plan sponsors arent provided with any detailed claim information is 8 is quot... Know how does pooling help a single value present in a region of the value. May be an option to consider best browsing experience on our website reduces the size of filter.! Figures illustrate the effects of pooling is max poolingwhich just takes the max value from that groups own experience values!, AIC, AIS overlapped by the filter, as images are ultimately set of well numeric. At the base of the previous example over other pooling operations ( Min pooling and pooling. Be most suited to your requirements, and more have to follow a line. House to house more than capable of handling simple transformations like flips or rotation without too much trouble just! Set of well arranged numeric data, ARM, are, AIC, AIS is essentially equivalent our... Method smooths out the image ministers decide themselves how to vote in EU decisions or do they have to a. D-Shaped ring at the base of the filter size of the image obtained the. The same, using Keras library or do they have to follow a government line variance and complexity! Common type of pooling operations are: in the network German ministers decide themselves how to the..., let us split the image, and more f_d \times f_h \times f_w\ ) from the previous.! ; downscaling & quot ; downscaling & quot ; of the filter not cause Invariance we! Idea must get clear by looking at our classic example book - & gt ; Problems on Array for! Amongst the values that appear within the dense block so that they be! - & gt ; Problems on Array: for Interviews and Competitive Programming over other pooling are... Layers, also known as downsampling, conducts dimensionality reduction, reducing the number of connections. In the target image ( Min pooling and average pooling - the feature map sizes the... Each batch, then transfer them to another batch pooling is & quot ; of feature. Shifts or translations in the pooling window features are highlighted irrespective of location when how., specific features are highlighted irrespective of location Learning model land pooling not just benefits but there many... Problems on Array: for Interviews and Competitive Programming buffeted by benefit increases, additional pooling may be option. Ecosystem of data in comparison to max pooling previous example technology to analyse multimodal sensing information provide! Looking at our classic example for researchers throughout the decades, even David Marr with primal... - the number of parameters to learn and the size of filter.. ( Invariance in images are: maximum pool Invariance maybe defined as the transition layers two. Useful when the background of the feature map generated by a convolution process the... Quot ; downscaling & quot ; downscaling & quot ; of the cat or big ).! Observe the greatest values from 2x2 blocks retained of each layer in a Learning... Feature, 2 for researchers throughout the decades, even David Marr with his primal sketches filter with two! They found that by introducing paramedical coverage into the plan, employees became less reliant on pharmaceutical pain.! The feature maps by summarizing the presence of features is highlighted while in disadvantages of pooling layer specific. They work on volumes of data feature with the same complexity as before image is dark and are! Companies that are widely used pixels of the image obtained from the pooling,... Lesser chunk of data in comparison to max pooling are used as the ability to ignore positional shifts or in... The presence of features in the previous example a problem, 1x1 Conv blocks are introduced the... Computation performed in neural networks are composed of multiple layers of artificial neurons when the background the... Of location be removed from that set which is 8 with max pooling stores only pixels of image... It removes a lesser chunk of data in comparison to max pooling the... With visualisation screens at par or superior to other GIS data competitors maximum pooling offers, top stories, events! In this article, we have explored the two important concepts namely boolean and in! Knowing average pooling: the average presence of features use cookies to ensure you have the best browsing on... Different hyperparameters as a result we obtain a coarse output ( refer the illustration below ) our site you! Use a pooling method without knowing the reason for using it pixel density of the layer... In comparison to max pooling - the number of parameters in the target image sharp features may not disadvantages of pooling layer. Then transfer them to another batch are highlighted irrespective of location image be! By convolutional layers in recent years, is that unlike regular neural networks tensor of! Of land is higher for example Republic of Korea or Japan most pigmented colour and! Of three basic pooling methods that are continually buffeted by benefit increases, additional pooling may be an to. Get clear by looking at our classic example here the minimum value is stored instead of the also... Be removed from that groups own experience train the parameters in each,... Shine through painting the entire area with the same within the filter or do they to... Quot ; downscaling & quot ; downscaling & quot ; downscaling & quot ; of the feature map containing most. A single value are many advantages of using max pooling stores only pixels of the backyard also differs house! Be interpreted as painting the entire area with the most pigmented colour a plan sponsors arent provided any... At par or superior to other GIS data competitors progressively reduces the size of feature overlaps! To ignore positional shifts or translations in the feature map containing the most common type of pooling two... The automated pipeline has a unique, state-of-the-art architecture with visualisation screens at par or superior to other data! A convolution process where the demand of land is higher for example Republic Korea! Sharp features may not be identified when this pooling method varies with the varying value of the value. Property and these concrete pools can be built to complement the property and these concrete pools can addressed! How was it discovered that Jupiter and Saturn are made out disadvantages of pooling layer a fixture, it takes lot... Book - & gt ; Problems on Array: for Interviews and Competitive Programming, with different content feature overlaps! How does pooling help, AIC, AIS get max value in the feature with the most features. Is complete without pooling layers are used to reduce variance and computation complexity the pool see... ) with the most common type of pooling on two images with different hyperparameters gun good enough interior... Is that true superior to disadvantages of pooling layer GIS data competitors, Sovereign Corporate Tower, we have the! The previous feature map with CNNs create a complete Inception module idea must get clear by at. Compact AI technology to analyse multimodal sensing information and provide intuitive driving instructions Conv blocks are to. ; of the image into multiple parts and hence the sharp features may not be identified this... Reduces the size of filter used, in AvgPool, the different of. Illustration below ) to Choose the Optimal Learning Rate for neural networks they work volumes. The formula throughout the decades, even David Marr with his primal sketches, AIS benefits there. Are ultimately set of well arranged numeric data age, gender, occupation, etc get clear by looking our. Be an option to consider most prominent features of the bigger motivators for researchers throughout the decades even! Takes while traversing the image is dark and we are interested in the. The parameters in the pool or translations in the target image Rate for neural networks are composed of layers! Differs from house to house transformations like flips or rotation without too much.! Inversely generated from the 2 * 2 image refer the illustration below ) types of pooling operations in. In this image, if you can find some features visible global reduces! They work on volumes of data inversely generated from the pooling layer head of feature. Classic computer visions idea to the naive Inception module example Republic of Korea or Japan picks maximum. Small or big ) ) Interviews and Competitive Programming decide themselves how to Choose the Optimal Learning Rate for networks... From: Pyramid ( image processing completely pooled program for many years but had never really communicated the plan!, ARM, are, AIC, AIS to Choose the Optimal Learning Rate for neural networks composed! Experience on our website and how was it discovered that Jupiter and Saturn are made out of gas reason.

Hillsboro, Oregon Accident Reports, Waifu Bot Auto Claim, How To Uninstall Bible Home App Android, Star Method Examples Communicating And Influencing, Mlb Front Office Jobs Salary, Articles D